Opened 2 years ago

Closed 2 years ago

#127 closed defect (wontfix)

Many `cwd` calls on the FTP session object

Reported by: schwa Owned by: schwa
Priority: minor Milestone:
Component: Library Version: 3.4
Keywords: cwd session Cc:


Migration to the new mock testing approach (scripted sessions) showed that there are frequent ftplib.FTP.cwd calls in a row. The reason is that every time _robust_ftp_command

    def _robust_ftp_command(self, command, path, descend_deeply=False):
        Run an FTP command on a path. The return value of the method
        is the return value of the command.

        If `descend_deeply` is true (the default is false), descend
        deeply, i. e. change the directory to the end of the path.
        # If we can't change to the yet-current directory, the code
        # below won't work (see below), so in this case rather raise
        # an exception than giving wrong results.
        # Some FTP servers don't behave as expected if the directory
        # portion of the path contains whitespace; some even yield
        # strange results if the command isn't executed in the
        # current directory. Therefore, change to the directory
        # which contains the item to run the command on and invoke
        # the command just there.
        # Remember old working directory.
        old_dir = self.getcwd()
            if descend_deeply:
                # Invoke the command in (not: on) the deepest directory.
                # Workaround for some servers that give recursive
                # listings when called with a dot as path; see issue #33,
                return command(self, "")
                # Invoke the command in the "next to last" directory.
                head, tail = self.path.split(path)
                return command(self, tail)

is used, we have one cwd call in _check_inaccessible_login_directory (which should be only needed once after opening the session), a second cwd to descend into the possibly nested directory and finally a third cwd to restore the old directory after the "descent".

In the tests it looks like cwd / is used all the time, but this is only because the directory we start from is /, so the directory into which we "descend" and which we restore later in the method happen to be the same.

Also keep in mind that most FTP sessions transfer files, and I imagine the overall network traffic and hence the needed time for the file transfers will outweigh the time for the cwd calls.

Change History (1)

comment:1 Changed 2 years ago by schwa

Resolution: wontfix
Status: newclosed

As said in the description, I assume the problem is minor in relation to other network operations and therefore there's no need to do anything about this right now. Nevertheless I wanted to enter the ticket for later reference, especially the reasoning about the minor effect on performance.

Because of this, I'm closing the ticket right now. If you find by measurements that the repeated cwd calls are a performance problem for you, please feel free to reopen the ticket and describe your problem.

Note: See TracTickets for help on using tickets.